May 23, 2005
ALL-TIME MEDALISTS
| 2005 | Doug Barber, Cleveland State (71-72-73 - 216) |
| 2004 | Nate Komsa, Youngstown State (72-70-75 - 217) |
| 2003 | Jeff Chapman, Butler (68-70-75 - 213) |
| 2002 | Jesse Hutchins, Wright State (67-72-75 - 214) |
| 2001 | Shaun Rezachek, UW-Green Bay (81-70-74 - 225) |
| 2000 | Billy Day, Wright State (70-74-66 - 210) |
| 1999 | Jason Hartman, Detroit (74-73-68 - 215) |
| 1998 | Shaun Rezachek, UW-Green Bay (72-78-72 - 225) |
| 1997 | Pete Samborsky, Wright State (72-71-69 - 212) |
| 1996 | Scott Hailes, Wright State (72-73-78 - 223) |
| 1995 | Brian Donohoe, Notre Dame (73-73-75 - 221) |
| 1993 | Brad Loomis, Xavier (76-74-73 - 223) |
| 1992 | David von Haefen, Xavier (78-73-75 - 226) |
| 1991 | Chris Dayton, Notre Dame (73-73-74 - 220) |
| 1990 | Mike O'Connell, Notre Dame (74-73 - 147) |
| 1989 | Jeff Lancaster, Xavier (73-76-74 - 223) |
| 1988 | Pat Mohan, Notre Dame (83-81-79 - 243) |
| 1987 | Brent Rubis, Saint Louis (78-75-77 - 230) |
| 1986 | Tom Nelson,Evansville (76-77-78 - 231) |
| 1985 | Nick Klassen, Oral Roberts (74-72-79 - 225) |
| 1984 | Darryl Court, Oral Roberts (76-75-70 - 221) |
| 1984 | Phil Thomas, Oklahoma City (73-77-76 - 226) |
| 1983 | Ashley Roestaff, Oral Roberts (76-79-69 - 224) |
| 1982 | Darryl James, Oral Roberts (68-73-69 - 210) |
| 1981 | Bryan Norton, Oral Roberts (73-71 - 144) |
| 1980 | Bill Glasson, Oral Roberts (67-68 - 135) |