June 7, 2005
| 2005 | ||
| UW-Green Bay | 817 | |
| Wright State | 735 | |
| UW-Milwaukee | 700 | |
| UIC | 483 | |
| Cleveland State | 311 | |
| Youngstown State | 294 | |
| Butler | 161 | |
| 2004 | ||
| Wright State | 802.50 | |
| UW-Green Bay | 783 | |
| UW-Milwaukee | 676 | |
| UIC | 429.50 | |
| Cleveland State | 339 | |
| Youngstown State | 273 | |
| Butler | 233 | |
| 2003 | ||
| Wright State | 779.50 | |
| UW-Green Bay | 738 | |
| UW-Milwaukee | 654 | |
| UIC | 440 | |
| Cleveland State | 307 | |
| Butler | 244 | |
| Youngstown State | 230.50 | |
| 2002 | ||
| Wright State | 755.50 | |
| UW-Green Bay | 722 | |
| UW-Milwaukee | 669.50 | |
| UIC | 461 | |
| Cleveland State | 287 | |
| Butler | 267 | |
| Youngstown State | 231 | |
| 2001 | ||
| UW-Milwaukee | 811.5 | |
| Wright State | 749.5 | |
| UW-Green-Bay | 671 | |
| UIC | 358.5 | |
| Cleveland State | 334 | |
| Butler | 281.5 | |
| 2000 | ||
| UW-Green Bay | 702.50 | |
| Wright State | 644 | |
| UW-Milwaukee | 632 | |
| Butler | 523.50 | |
| UIC | 352 | |
| Cleveland State | 337 | |
| 1999 | ||
| Wright State | 748 | |
| UW-Green Bay | 657 | |
| UW-Milwaukee | 523 | |
| UIC | 493 | |
| Cleveland State | 445 | |
| Butler | 407 | |
| 1998 | ||
| Wisconsin-Green Bay | 899 | |
| Wright State | 648 | |
| Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 588 | |
| Illinois-Chicago | 442 | |
| Butler | 303 | |
| Cleveland State | 284 | |
| 1997 | ||
| Wright State | 837 | |
| UW-Green Bay | 671.5 | |
| Northern Illinois | 644.5 | |
| UW-Milwaukee | 395.5 | |
| UIC | 355 | |
| Cleveland State | 260 | |
| Butler | 151.5 | |
| 1996 | ||
| Wright State | 888 | |
| Northern Illinois | 721 | |
| Wisconsin-Green Bay | 633 | |
| Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 337 | |
| Illinois-Chicago | 309.5 | |
| Cleveland State | 268 | |
| Butler | 201.5 | |
| 1995 | ||
| Notre Dame | 749 | |
| Wright State | 613 | |
| Northern Illinois | 552 | |
| La Salle | 458 | |
| Wisconsin-Green Bay | 387 | |
| Cleveland State | 227 | |
| Illinois-Chicago | 198 | |
| Wisconsin-Milwaukee | 189.5 | |
| Butler | 182.5 | |
| Xavier | 98 | |
| 1994 | ||
| Notre Dame | 841 | |
| La Salle | 830 | |
| Evansville | 593 | |
| Butler | 459 | |
| Xavier | 372 | |
| 1993 | ||
| Notre Dame | 1,183 | |
| Evansville | 891 | |
| La Salle | 770 | |
| Butler | 518 | |
| Duquesne | 493 | |
| Xavier | 405 | |
| 1992 | ||
| Notre Dame | 978.5 | |
| Evansville | 796 | |
| Butler | 499 | |
| Xavier | 413 | |
| 1991 | ||
| Notre Dame | 897 | |
| Saint Louis | 718 | |
| Evansville | 608 | |
| Butler | 408 | |
| Xavier | 359 | |
| 1990 | ||
| Notre Dame | 1,078 | |
| Saint Louis | 589 | |
| Xavier | 531 | |
| Evansville | 492 | |
| Butler | 341 | |
| 1989 | ||
| Notre Dame | 634 | |
| Saint Louis | 394 | |
| Evansville | 360 | |
| Xavier | 317 | |
| Butler | 258 | |
| 1988 | ||
| Notre Dame | 634 | |
| Evansville | 573 | |
| Xavier | 269 | |
| Butler | 244 | |
| Saint Louis | 207 | |
| 1987 | ||
| Evansville | 651 | |
| Butler | 494 | |
| Oral Roberts | 302 | |
| Saint Louis | 269 | |
| Xavier | 218 | |