Dec. 15, 2005
PAST TEAM CHAMPIONS AND RUNNERS-UP
| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | Site |
| 2005 | Butler | Loyola | Yellow Springs, Ohio |
| 2004 | Butler | Loyola | Kenosha, Wisconsin |
| 2003 | Butler | Loyola | Chicago, Illinois |
| 2002 | Butler | Loyola | Chicago, Illinois |
| 2001 | Loyola | Butler | Chicago, Illinois |
| 2000 | Loyola | Butler | Green Bay, Wisconsin |
| 1999 | Butler | Loyola | Detroit, Michigan |
| 1998 | Butler | Loyola | Indianapolis, Indiana |
| 1997 | Butler | Detroit/Loyola | Kettering, Ohio |
| 1996 | Butler | Loyola | DeKalb, Illinois |
| 1995 | Loyola | Butler | Glendale, Wisconsin |
| 1994 | Notre Dame | Loyola | Chicago, Illinois |
| 1993 | Notre Dame | Loyola | Media, Pennsyslvania |
| 1992 | Notre Dame | Loyola | Cincinnati, Ohio |
| 1991 | Loyola | Notre Dame | Chicago, Illinois |
| 1990 | Notre Dame | Loyola | Northville, Michigan |
| 1989 | Dayton | Notre Dame | Milwaukee, Wisconsin |
| 1988 | Dayton | Notre Dame | Chicago, Illinois |
| 1987 | Detroit | Loyola | Indianapolis, Indiana |
| 1986 | Detroit | Loyola | Indianapolis, Indiana |